Explore the Full Spectrum of Leadership and Life Mastery
Issue #157 Are You an Apple or Jell-O? The Hidden Pressure to Live Up to Our Past Success
Brad Pedersen
November 19, 2026
•
8 min read
.jpg)
.webp)
A few newsletters ago, I shared the story of being fired from a company I had co-founded. It was one of the more painful experiences of my entrepreneurial journey, particularly because I had invested so much of my life into building something I cared deeply about.
Eventually, as I began accepting that this chapter of my life had ended, something unexpected emerged alongside the disappointment. Relief. While I wouldn’t have chosen the circumstances of my departure, I began to appreciate that they had created an opportunity to reconsider what I wanted my life to look like and where I wanted to invest my energy going forward.
If you missed that earlier story, you can read it HERE.
What I haven’t shared as much about is what happened next.
After spending years in the toy industry, helping build a company from nothing into a business of significance, I suddenly found myself contemplating an entirely different future. I had accumulated considerable experience, developed meaningful relationships and learned valuable lessons through both success and failure. Yet I was now entering a new industry, facing unfamiliar problems and pursuing opportunities where my previous accomplishments offered no guarantee of future success.
There was something genuinely exciting about that possibility. I’ve always enjoyed the creative challenge of entrepreneurship, particularly the opportunity to take an idea, assemble the right people and resources, and build something meaningful from the ground up. Starting over offered the chance to learn, experiment and develop capabilities that might never have emerged had I remained where I was.
But alongside that excitement was another feeling I couldn’t entirely ignore: the pressure to prove myself.
Could I do it again? Could I build something equally successful in an industry where I didn’t have the benefit of years of experience? Would the lessons I’d learned translate into a different environment? And perhaps most importantly, how would I feel about myself if I couldn’t?
I’ve been reflecting on those questions recently because they’ve helped me recognize something about the relationship between our accomplishments, our motivations and the identity we develop along the way.
The Pressure to Prove
One of the more humbling realizations about my experience in the toy business is recognizing how much of our extraordinary outcome depended on circumstances beyond my control.
That isn’t to suggest we didn’t work hard. We certainly did. But I also recognize that hard work and good decisions don’t guarantee extraordinary results. In our case, there was a remarkable convergence of circumstances, relationships and timing that created opportunities we could never have manufactured through effort alone.
I benefited from being in the right place, with the right dynamics, at the right time.
And while I remain grateful for what we accomplished, that recognition introduced an interesting tension when I found myself starting over.
If so much of my previous success had depended on favourable circumstances, could I reasonably expect to achieve something comparable again? Had I developed the capabilities necessary to succeed in an entirely different industry, or had I simply benefited from an unusual set of opportunities that might never present themselves again?
I suspect many people who have experienced meaningful achievement in business can relate to this feeling. The accomplishments we’re most proud of can gradually become the standards against which we measure everything that follows.
What was once a source of satisfaction can become an unexpected burden when we begin believing that our future must somehow prove the validity of our past.
I’ve come to recognize that the desire to prove myself has been a powerful motivator throughout my life, and I suspect it’s something I’ll always wrestle with. The need to prove can be an incredibly effective fuel. It burns hot, providing the energy and determination to pursue ambitious goals, overcome obstacles and accomplish things we might otherwise have considered impossible.
And there are seasons of life when proving ourselves is both healthy and appropriate. But I’ve also come to appreciate that there’s an important distinction between being motivated by what we’re trying to prove and being inspired by who we’re aspiring to become.
I’ve found it helpful to consider this through the lens of what I would want people to say about me at my funeral. Not the businesses I built, the money I earned or the recognition I received, but the characteristics that defined how I lived. Was I generous, courageous, curious and kind? Did I invest in meaningful relationships? Did I use whatever opportunities and abilities I’d been given to make a positive difference in the lives of others?
Those questions invite a different kind of ambition. One that isn’t primarily concerned with proving our worth, but with becoming someone whose life reflects what we genuinely value.
One of the unintended consequences of success is that the more we’ve accomplished, the more we can become concerned about protecting it. Our desire to preserve what we’ve already achieved can gradually outweigh our willingness to discover what we might still become.
Instead of being inspired by what the future might hold, we become preoccupied with whether it will measure up to our past.
Are You an Apple or Jell-O?
I once heard Vijay use an analogy comparing Jell-O with an apple that I have come to love.
Jell-O requires a mould to give it shape. Without something external to contain it, it has no inherent structure capable of determining its form. Its shape is determined by the container surrounding it. Jell-O is formed from the outside
An apple, on the other hand, grows from the inside out. It has a core that determines its structure and shape. While it depends on sunlight, water and nutrients from its environment, those external conditions support its growth rather than determine what it is. An apple is transformed, from the inside.
I believe we should approach our lives in much the same way.
When our sense of identity is shaped primarily by external measures of success, we become dependent on those measures to tell us who we are and whether we’re doing well. Our accomplishments, possessions, titles and reputations become the moulds that give us our shape.
As long as those circumstances remain favourable, we may feel confident and satisfied. But when they’re threatened, so is the identity we’ve constructed around them.
Looking back, I can recognize how much of my identity had become connected to my business. When that chapter ended unexpectedly, I wasn’t simply confronting the loss of a position or an opportunity. I was also confronting the uncomfortable question of who I was without something that had occupied such a significant place in my life.
And even as I began exploring new possibilities, I could recognize how easily the desire to prove myself might become another external measure of my worth.
That’s what makes this distinction challenging. We can intellectually recognize that our worth isn’t determined by our accomplishments while still feeling a powerful emotional need to achieve them.
The apple offers a different way of thinking about this.
Rather than allowing external circumstances to determine our identity, we can become increasingly intentional about developing an internal foundation grounded in our values, character, relationships and sense of purpose.
These are the qualities that ultimately define the person we become. They’re reflected in how we treat others, the challenges we’re willing to embrace, the promises we keep and the contributions that we make. They’re also much closer to the characteristics we’d hope people would remember about us when our lives are over.
That doesn’t mean becoming indifferent to achievement or abandoning our ambitions. An apple still needs a favourable environment to flourish, just as we benefit from encouragement, recognition and the rewards of our efforts.
But those things become resources that support our growth rather than determine our identity. Our accomplishments become expressions of the person we’re becoming rather than the foundation upon which our worth depends.
Becoming Rather Than Proving
I wish I could say that recognizing this distinction eliminated my desire to prove myself. It hasn’t.
Even today, I recognize moments when I’m inspired by the possibility of accomplishing something meaningful and others when I’m more concerned about how my efforts will compare with what I’ve achieved before.
I’ve come to believe that the objective isn’t to eliminate every extrinsic motivation from our lives. I’m not sure that’s realistic, or even desirable. Instead, the challenge is developing enough self-awareness to recognize what’s driving us and, when necessary, choosing to change the fuel behind our ambition.
That means recognizing when we’re running on dirty fuel, driven by insecurity, fear or the need for external validation, and choosing cleaner fuel inspired by who we aspire to become, the values we want to live by and the contribution we hope to make.
Our goals don’t necessarily need to change. We can still pursue ambitious opportunities and meaningful accomplishments. But shifting from being pushed by what we’re trying to prove to being pulled toward who we aspire to become can fundamentally change how we experience the journey.
For me, it’s an ongoing practice rather than a destination I’ve reached. I’m learning that I don’t need to recreate my past accomplishments to prove that the next chapter of my life is worthwhile. I can remain ambitious, embrace unfamiliar challenges and enjoy building something meaningful without requiring the outcome to validate who I am.
And when I recognize that familiar desire to prove myself, the most useful response isn’t to suppress it, but to ask whether it’s helping me move toward the person I aspire to become or pulling me back toward an identity I’m afraid of losing.
One Question
As you reflect on this season of your life, how much of what you’re pursuing is inspired by the person you want to become, and how much is driven by the need to prove or protect who you’ve been?
New here?
Discover Where You're Thriving and Ready to Grow


Subscribe to Full Spectrum Newsletter
Get insights delivered to your inbox monthly.
Subscribe to Full Spectrum Newsletter
Get insights delivered to your inbox monthly.
